Irresistible Butterfinger Cake Recipe You’ll Love to Make

butterfinger cake recipe is the kind of dessert I make when I need something fun, fast, and basically guaranteed to disappear. You know those days when you want a sweet treat that feels like a party, but you do not want to mess with fancy layers or delicate frosting tricks? This is that cake. It is chocolatey, gooey, and packed with crunchy candy bits that make everyone go back for seconds. I started making it for potlucks, then it turned into my go to for birthdays and game nights. If you have a box of cake mix and a few simple add ons, you are already halfway there. If you want to learn more about other cake recipes.

Butterfinger Cake Recipe Ingredients

Print

Let us talk ingredients, because this is where the magic happens. The base is easy, but the add ons are what give that classic candy bar vibe. I like keeping everything measured and ready before I start, because once the cake is baked, you move pretty quickly with the toppings.

• Chocolate cake mix (plus the eggs, oil, and water it calls for)
• Sweetened condensed milk (one can)
• Caramel sauce (store bought is totally fine)
• Whipped topping (like Cool Whip, thawed)
• Butterfinger candy bars (crushed, and do not be shy with them)
• Optional but amazing: chocolate syrup, mini chocolate chips, a pinch of salt

If you like baking from scratch, you can absolutely use your favorite homemade chocolate cake. But I am telling you honestly, the boxed mix works so well here that I never feel guilty about it.

Also, if you are into other easy chocolate desserts, I usually keep a few “crowd” recipes in rotation. I would link you to them here, but I was given an empty list for internal links, so I cannot add the clickable internal links you asked for without URLs.

How to Make a Butterfinger Cake

This is the part where the cake turns into that gooey, poke style dessert people get obsessed with. It is not hard at all, but the order matters. You want the cake warm when the good stuff gets poured in, so it can soak down into those little holes.

Here is how I do it in my kitchen:

• Preheat your oven and bake the chocolate cake in a 9×13 pan based on the package directions.
• Let it cool for about 10 minutes. You want it warm, not scorching hot.
• Use the handle of a wooden spoon to poke holes all over the top. Go deep, but do not destroy the cake.
• Pour the sweetened condensed milk evenly over the cake, making sure it drips into the holes.
• Drizzle caramel sauce all over the top. I go in a zigzag pattern so every slice gets some.
• Let the cake cool completely.
• Spread the whipped topping on top like an easy frosting.
• Finish with a thick layer of crushed Butterfinger.

That is the whole thing. And yes, it tastes even better after a little chill time. The best part is the texture: soft chocolate cake, sticky caramel pockets, and that crunchy candy topping. This butterfinger cake recipe is basically comfort food, but in dessert form.

I made this for my kid’s birthday and people were scraping the pan. One friend asked for the recipe before she even finished her first slice. It is officially my new party dessert.

Sarah P.

Butterfinger Cake Recipe Tips

I have made this enough times to learn a few little things that make it come out better every time. None of these are complicated. They are just the kind of practical stuff you only notice after you have done it a few times.

Crush the candy the easy way

Put the Butterfinger bars in a zip top bag and crush them with a rolling pin. Do not pulverize them into dust. You want a mix of small chunks and crumbs so the topping has crunch.

Do not rush the cooling step

Wait until the cake is completely cool before adding the whipped topping. If the cake is warm, the topping melts and gets weird and runny. Still tasty, but not as pretty.

Make the flavors pop

A tiny pinch of salt over the caramel layer sounds odd, but it makes the chocolate and caramel taste even richer. Not required, just a little trick I love.

And one more thing: if you are making this for a crowd, double up on the candy topping. People always want that crunchy part in every bite. This butterfinger cake recipe is very forgiving, so you can adjust the amounts to your taste.

Should I Refrigerate Cake Before Frosting?

For this cake, I say yes, or at least let it cool fully at room temperature first. Since we are using whipped topping, chilling helps it set nicely and makes the whole dessert easier to slice.

My usual routine is simple:

Bake it, poke it, pour the condensed milk and caramel, then let it sit on the counter until it is not warm anymore. After that, I pop it in the fridge for 30 to 60 minutes. Then I add the whipped topping and candy.

If you are in a hurry, you can spread the topping once the cake is fully cool. But if your kitchen runs warm like mine does, that quick chill makes everything neater.

How to Store Chocolate Butterfinger Cake

This is one of those desserts that actually stores really well. The flavors soak in, and the cake stays moist for days. The only downside is the candy topping can soften over time, but honestly it still tastes great.

Here is what works best:

• Refrigerate it covered in the pan with foil or plastic wrap.
• It is best within 3 to 4 days.
• If you want the topping crunchier, add a fresh sprinkle of crushed Butterfinger right before serving.

Freezing is possible too. Freeze the cake without the whipped topping if you can, then thaw and top it later. If you freeze it fully assembled, it is still edible, but the texture of the whipped topping and candy is a little different after thawing.

This butterfinger cake recipe is also a great make ahead dessert. I love making it the night before a get together, because it is one less thing to stress about.

Common Questions

A sweet little push to go bake it

If you want a dessert that feels nostalgic, easy, and seriously satisfying, this butterfinger cake recipe is a solid choice. It is simple enough for a weeknight, but it still looks and tastes like something you brought to impress people.

If you want to compare little variations, you can check out Butterfinger Cake – Plain Chicken, Butterfinger ® Cake – Confessions of a Baking Queen, and How to Make a Butterfinger Cake – The First Year. Now grab that pan, crush those candy bars, and make it happen. I promise your future self is going to be really happy you did.